Archive for the 'Minutes' Category

Digital Storytelling Meeting Reflections

Monday, April 14th, 2008

In our last meeting we talked about Digital Storytelling, and we invited Professor Kate McDowell to take the lead in our discussions. We ended up talking about a number of issues, including:

  • Definitions of digital storytelling:
    • What counts as digital storytelling? What does not?
    • How broad a definition of digital storytelling is possible? E.g., Youtube videos, discussion board posts, radio broadcasts, etc.?
    • What are meaningful possible boundaries for such a definition?
    • What do the people who call their work “digital storytelling” do? What do they consider to be “digital storytelling”?
  • Digital storytelling as folklore:
    • Digital storytelling that is folklore; digital storytelling that is not folklore.
    • Patterns of dynamism and conservatism (Toelken) in digital storytelling.
  • Examples of digital storytelling, especially digital artifacts specifically referred to by their creators as being digital storytelling
  • A description of various dimentions of digital vs. traditional storytelling developed by Professor McDowell.
  • Different conceptions of how to approach thinking about digital storytelling:
    • We noticed that there seemed to be some miscommunication going on between those of us who were used to thinking about digital storytelling from a design perspective, and those of us who were used to thinking about digital storytelling from a research or practice perspective.

Below I have included our original invitation, for those interested in our original plan.

Next week Thursday (4/10/2008) we will be holding an Eclectic Design
Research Group (EDRG) meeting from 2:00 pm to 4:00 pm in the ISRL (LIS
room 340) on Digital Storytelling. Kate McDowell will be leading the
session, and you are all invited to attend. We can skype in people who
are interested in joining the discussion but are unable to be on
campus (it works ok). Our agenda is as follows:

Kate will present:
–How LEEP storytelling classes are currently taught, including
technology and performance philosophy
–The relative strengths of traditional and digital storytelling, and
how they can be complementary

Then we will be discussing the following stories/sites/topics/articles:

Definitions of Digital Storytelling:

–Center for Digital Storytelling
http://www.storycenter.org/,
especially their highlighted example story:
http://www.storycenter.org/momquicktime.html

–Educational Uses of Digital Storytelling
http://www.coe.uh.edu/digitalstorytelling/default.htm
especially their highlighted example story:
http://www.wmich.edu/pt3/ds/look.html

(with Matt Beth)
–Methods of digital storytelling communication (via LEEP):

e.g., real-time screen captures to distribute (or some other mechanism)

Research Papers:

McDowell, Kate. Distance and Presence: A Case Study of Performance
in Two Online Storytelling Courses. Forthcoming in Storytelling,
Self, Society, Sept 2008
* Please email me to obtain a copy of this document if you think you
might be able to attend - it is not for public consumption but can be
shared for the purposes of our discussion.

Kelleher, C. and R. Pausch. Lessons Learned from Designing a
Programming System to Support Middle School Girls Creating Animated
Stories. 2006 IEEE Symposium on Visual Languages and Human-Centric
Computing. [ieee pdf], linked from
http://www.alice.org/kelleher/storytelling/papers.html

Alison Druin’s Kidpad:
http://www.cs.umd.edu/hcil/kiddesign/kidpad.shtml
— “KidPad: a design collaboration between children, technologists,
and educators”
—- http://portal.acm.org/citation.cfm?id=258866&dl=ACM&coll=GUIDE

Brian Bailey’s Clover
http://orchid.cs.uiuc.edu/projects/clover/index.html
— “Clover: Connecting technology and character education using
personally-constructed animated vignettes”
—- http://portal.acm.org/citation.cfm?id=1221400

— “Designing storytelling technologies to encouraging collaboration
between young children”
—- http://portal.acm.org/citation.cfm?id=332502&coll=portal&dl=ACM&CFID=58138146&CFTOKEN=33036891

We look forward to seeing you there!

Minutes 2006-08-31

Thursday, August 31st, 2006

Need to update the 1998 paper on CSCW in Digital Libraries in preparation for i-Conference.

Invitation to IRB Staff to discuss application of IRB for GSLIS Research

Concrete plausible questions for clarification.

  1. Talk to IRB about how they would like to work with GSLIS.
  2. Talk to IRB about whether we can develop a larger scale permission for classes.
  3. A system similar to Waikato, where complex things require a form, other types of testing requires IRB being aware of the work and receiving informal clearance to proceed. May require up front training and work.

Document requirements that are not explicitly required on the form. e.g.location of principal investigators.

How is IRB handled in other schools. May be an issue in faculty hiring. e.g. faculty may be attracted to institutions with cooperative IRB proceedures.

“wizard of oz” studies where software hasn’t been written yet.

Cameron has added a page to the Confluence wiki that will have example IRB forms attached.

Mike met with ACM president and faculty advisor and there was enthusiasm for a Scrapheap challenge. Need to find examples for information science. How would the contest be run. What kinds of challenges would interest both CS and LIS students.

Cosnider creating a panel of CSCW experts outside of UIUC to create the challenge.

Next week RSS

  • how to manage feeds
  • how do I pick feeds
  • OPML and feed interoperability

Reference Software

Minutes from 24 August, 2006

Thursday, August 24th, 2006

More brainstorming of meeting topics

Here are some more topics in addition to the ones we came up with last week for topics to discuss this semester/year.

  • CSCW Boundaries
  • Second-Life
    • A-Loft hotel in Second life
    • http://news.com.com/2300-1043_3-6104949-1.html?tag=ne.gall.pg
  • Rapid evaluation techniques
    • Feedback from users
    • Benefits, limitations of various methods
  • Incremental Learning
  • Design in the “broad-sense” - beyond thinking about design on a computer or software design. “Socio-technical systems design”
    • Set of problems, questions, context, background

CHAMP - Cultural Heritage and Museum Practices

How can you do a series of qualitative, iterative studies?

Putting the ECSCW proceedings online.

Upcoming deadlines

  • CHI Tutorials - September 1, 2006
  • SIGCSE 2007 - September 8, 2006
  • CSCW Workshop Submissions - September 15, 2006
  • HICSS 2007 Revisions due - September 15, 2006
  • Museums and the Web - September 30, 2006
  • CHI Papers & Notes - September 29, 2006
  • C&C 2007 - December 15, 2006

Scrapheap Challenge @ UIUC

  • ACM/ASIS&T collab.
  • Microsoft donate a “prize”?
  • Beginning of next term?

Moving and organizing

  • Confluence Wiki
  • MikeWiki
  • Design website
  • Calendar?

IRB

  • Generate a list of topics and questions to ask of IRB
  • What topics/research ideas/etc are in the purvue of IRB
  • Research - Human Subjects Research - Exempt - Not Research - Not HS Research
  • Edge cases -
    • Editing
    • Usability interviews
    • Memoires?
    • Lived-research
    • Participant/researcher - post stuff on the web, to then be able to use it.
  • Speed up process
  • Did some stuff and in retrospect want to get it approved
  • Rapid iteration, build-test-evaluate-build-test-eval-etc

Next Week, 31 August, 2006

  • IRB
  • RSS - different versions, etc.
  • Aggregators